nerd radio

Tune in live Thursday from 9pm est

SERIES REVIEW: FTN reviews Red Dwarf X or ‘Oh Smeg it: The Return of Red Dwarf’

November 24th, 2012 by Dave Bowling 2 Comments


Like many people I was overjoyed at the news of Red Dwarf coming back for a new series.  When looking at it with 20/20 rose-tinted vision Red Dwarf was brilliant, but how does the new Series 10 stack up to the classics?


Leaving aside the god-awfulness that was Series VII, Series VIII was a return to form that sadly never gave us any real closure.  Back to Earth was unfortunately made on a budget of about 20p and didn’t explain how the ship survived the end of Season eight.  But no matter since it was about as funny as watching a plane crash in slow motion.

So how does Series ten fair?  Sadly, not well to begin with.  The opening episode Trojan was a mess, with Lister and the Cat becoming obsessed with a shopping TV channel and Rimmer miraculously coming into contact with the hologram of his dead brother.  It’s not that it was particularly bad, just that there was something missing that you can’t quite put your finger on.  The moose gag was pretty entertaining though.

Fathers and Suns was much better, however.  Not quite a return to form but the brilliance of Lister’s video conversations with his drunken self playing ‘dad’ lifts the whole show.  The new ship’s computer was nowhere near as entertaining as Holly, despite the whole predictive text thing of it figuring out what orders would be before they’re given.  Doug, mate, seriously just get Norman Lovett on board for the next season.  Please.

Lemons.  Accurately named.  Yet another stupid plot about reaching Earth via time travel and not finding a way to get back to around Lister and Rimmer’s own time.  And the whole alternative Christianity thing has seriously been done to death in recent years (ok, maybe I’m prejudiced by the number of conspiracy theory potboilers I’ve been reading lately, but still…).  And the plot twist wasn’t really that twisty, realistically you could’ve seen it coming a mile off.  The only thing that made the episode was the closing gag, sadly this appears to be on a par with the much-maligned Season seven.  Or Meltdown.

Entangled, on the other hand, was a big improvement.  I loved Lister losing Starbug and Rimmer in a card game to garbage-eating GELFs, but more so everybody’s reaction to the bomb strapped to his crotch.  Danny John-Jules and Robert Llewellyn deserve some sort of award for having to deliver the ‘quantum-tangled’ Cat and Kryten’s lines simultaneously – maybe the first FTN Award for Acting Aptitude In The Face Of Terrible Odds?  If there was a downside to this episode it’s the stasisised Professor Edgington, a scientist with a PhD in being wrong.

Once again, the odd numbered episodes showed a decided lack of quality with Dear Dave.  We find Lister in a love triangle with two vending machines while trying to find a letter from an ex-girlfriend explaining whether he is a dad or not.  Largely a fairly flat episode with misfiring farcical jokes.  The only two gags that saved the episode were Lister decrying his ex-girlfriend as a ‘slag’ when he finds out he isn’t a dad after all, and the retread of the ‘you’ll bonk anything’ routine from Polymorph when Lister knocks one of the vending machines over.

But finally the season goes out on a real high with The Beginning.  Rimmer becomes a self-confessed working class hero, the crew is menaced by rogue simulants and a mad burnt-out droid who seems to be channelling Eli Wallach challenges Lister to endless duels across time and space as a way of relieving boredom.  Best of all is the final “explanation” about how Rimmer saved the ship in Season 8.  Brilliance, proving that Doug Naylor does still have the goods after all these years.

So, a little hit and miss.  Bit of a mixed bag but overall a great effort.  I know UKTV only managed to produce the show on a budget of a staff whip-round and whatever they found down the back of the sofa but with a few extra quid the old girl could still produce the goods in the future.  So the big question remains: buy the DVD or not?

…Yep, it’s out now…

And by the way, you keel my brother!

3.5 out of 5 Nerds

Let us know your thoughts below, @NerdFollowing on Twitter or on Facebook

Dave was born at an early age to parents of both sexes. He has been a self-confessed geek for as long as he can remember, having been raised through the 80s on a steady diet of Doctor Who, Star Trek, Red Dwarf and (sigh) Knight Rider. Throw the usual assortment of Saturday morning cartoons into the mix and we have something quite exceptional: someone with an encyclopaedic knowledge of utter tosh; a love of giant robots and spaceships fighting; and the strange desire to leap tall buildings in a single bound while wearing his underpants over his trousers. The death ray is currently in the works and one day you shall all bow to him, his giant space station and fleet of funky orange space shuttles...

  • rogue commentor

    Well, this was certainly different, if for nothing else due to the fact you consider Series VIII a return to form while most regard it as being worse than or equivalent to VII (for good reason). Your views on X are also rather off the beaten track, given that both Lemons and Trojan were argued as being the stronger episodes alongside The Beginning (for good reason); Fathers and Suns had the unfortunate Taiwan Tony, Dear Dave is problematic for a variety of reasons although you actually seemed to enjoy some of the most maligned parts, and Entangled had production issues up the yin yang. And to be perfectly honest, all the complaining about the lack of Holly is beginning to become really grating when the character has really not been a part of the show for a very long time and also because it shows an intense level of ignorance on the people that bring it up’s part not to know about the fact that Norman Lovett himself fell out of love with the show in a very big way (although he has been singing a slightly different tune of late). I would say this review is kind of a mess, but then, opinions can differ.

    • followingthenerd

      The difficult thing about reviews is that everyone has different opinions and it often boils down to who gets to the review first. But it would be a boring old world if everyone felt the same, wouldn’t it? As for the Holly thing, it’s hardly ignorance but rather passion for the character regardless of the circumstances I think Dave is entitled to say he misses the character (Marc)

Proudly Powered By WordPress