nerd radio

Get ready for the new daily show


October 25th, 2013 by Andrew McCarroll Comments

“Start telling the stories that only you can tell. Because there will always be better writers than you, and there will always be smarter writers than you, and there will always be, you know, people who are much better at doing this or doing that, but you are the only you.”

― Neil Gaiman


Stan Lee, Frank Millar, Alan Moore, Alex Ross, Garth Ennis, Geoff Johns, Mark Millar – ask any comic book fan to remove one name that they feel should not be on that list and most would plump for the latter, the man who came tied 20th with Jim Starlin in a recent poll of best comic writers of all time. He has been called everything from racist, sexist, homophobic and also bizarrely, pro-gay. He is perhaps the most divisive figure in comics but he is also unquestionably one of the greats. With a C.V. that includes among others Red Son, Old Man Logan, Kick Ass, X-Men and The Ultimates, Millar’s name is seldom mentioned when the question of comic creating immortals is raised. Put simply, Mark Millar is the single most underrated comic writer in history. The word underrated is a strange thing to label a man who has reshaped and re-launched not just singular titles, but with Civil War, changed the entire Marvel Universe!! And films based both directly and indirectly on his work have grossed billions.

He has often been criticized, as has most of the industry, of depicting women in a negative light. Yet, in ‘Hit-Girl’ he has created one of the most iconic female characters in years. He turned the leader of Earth’s Mightiest Heroes from the Hoff into a bad ass Samuel L Jackson look-a-like. It’s been said that he can do nothing outside of hardcore violence, yet his children’s comic Kindergarten Heroes is currently being adapted for the big screen. He has also never shied away from his nerd side, citing one of his favorite things about shooting ‘Kick Ass’ was being able to spend hours on the old ‘Star Wars’ cantina set. He was also famously kicked off the set of The Dark Knight after being discovered sitting on the Bat Pod. Millar has committed the ultimate sin in what until recently was very much a niche industry, he became successful and popular.

Regardless of your personal feelings of the man, his run on The Ultimates completely revived a title that had long became stagnant and was blue touch paper that would ignite the ‘Avengers’ into the block busting juggernaught it currently is. Littered with iconic moments and brilliant one liners (SURRENDER??!! You think this letter on my head stands for France?), Millar chose not to portray the heroes as all conquering good guys, going so far as to make one of their own as much of a villain as Chitauri. These moralistic shades of grey are ones he would revisit in Civil War, where he takes the ultimate symbol of the U.S. – Captain America – and makes him turn against the government in opposition to the Superhuman Registration Act, a move that would split the Marvel universe in half and ultimately cost Steve Rogers his life.

Most of his work seems to stem from high concept “what if” questions you find in most comic stores. What if Superman landed in Russia? What if a normal person tried to become a superhero? Idea’s that seem so obvious when you hear them that you wonder why you didn’t come up with them yourself. What Millar does so well is expand on seemingly shallow concepts and take them in directions you could never have imagined while never surrendering interest, humor or indeed drama in his storylines. Hank Pym physically abusing his wife and Spiderman’s unmasking are great examples of Millar flexing his dramatic muscles as he handles these storylines with heft and consequence that many of his detractors thought he was incapable of.

Millar’s tendency for shock and awe has been molded by one of the earliest comics he read which featured the death of Gwen Stacy. As introductions to the medium go it’s slightly cooler then my own gateway, which was “Roger the Dodger”. Despite successes for both Marvel and DC, the sting of having his work on The Authority, censored by DC, never quite escaped him and although some of his more far out there ideas (turning the entire Marvel universe into zombies or having a horny Hulk looking to smash Freddie Prinze Jr out of a love triangle) went through untouched, there was a sense that Millar was holding back and in 2004 he launched his own creator owned line called Millarworld. Here he is able to write what he wants, with whom he wants and he retains 100% ownership of all his characters. It is here that Millar has developed some of his most iconic creations such as Kick Ass, Wanted, Nemesis, and Superior and is currently midway through the spectacular Jupiter’s Legacy.

Millar’s reach has now extended beyond comics into movies, both in adapting his own work and as a creative consultant for 20th Century Fox. Ironically, Matthew Vaughan left the Fox produced Days of Futures Past in order to direct the adaptation of Millar’s Secret Service comic. It was seen as a strange step for a man who said that “Movies are just 100 million dollar adverts for my books” but few would back against him finding success in this field also, his handling of Jim Carrey’s crisis of conscience was expertly done. Millar currently has 6 of his titles in some stage of movie development along with overseeing the latest X-Men and Fantastic Four installments. However, his work on Jupiter’s Legacy has shown he has not taken his eye off the ball when it comes to his first passion.

Regardless of all his extra endeavors I am a Mark Millar fan for one reason, his writing. No matter what subject the controversial Scotsman turns his pen to; it is never less than engaging. Whatever missteps I may feel he has taken, most notably the last page of Wanted which made me want to set fire to the book, he more than counter acts this with countless moments of action, excitement, humor and heartbreak. Superior’s Simon Pooni, tortured with the choice of living as a crippled high school student or a soulless Superman, is incredibly touching. Logan, looking upon the bones of his fallen friends, is chilling and Hawkeyes “Run” moment is pure heart pumping brilliance. Every single title of Millar’s that I have ever picked up has left some impression on me. His work, divisive as it may be, is never dull or apathetic. He never fails to intrigue, uplift and excite and that is the sign of a true artist.


Andrew McCarroll never quite built on the dizzying career heights that he hit at 6 years old, when as a member of the “Ghostbusters” he would charge his neighbours to remove any unwanted spectres. Now retired from slaying spooks, he spends his time obsessing over superheroes (especially Batman) and devouring shows like Dexter, Game of Thrones and Archer in a manner that would make Galactus proud. You can follow his rants on twitter @andymc1983